This list is in the order as they appeared on the original airing of the episode.
Guest Starring
- JoBeth Williams as Sandra Harding
- Joshua Malina as Asst. US Attorney David Rosen
- Bellamy Young as First Lady Mellie Grant
- Matt Letscher as Billy Chambers
- Liza Weil as Amanda Tanner
- Brendan Hines as Gideon Wallace
- Curtis Armstrong as Attorney Cole
- Michael Cassidy as Travis Harding
- Ellen Woglom as Helen Fisher
- Jerrika Hinton as Hannah
Co-Starring
- Mina Badie as Asst. US Attorney Jane Powell
- Chet Grissom as Charles
- Damien Leake as Judge Leo Theroux
- Ajarae Coleman as Meryl
- Frank Novak as Juror #6 / Old Marine Juror
- Rob Welsh as Juror #10 / Goth-Dude Juror
- Mason Rae as Blonde
Uncredited
- Julianna Therese Barninger as Rachel Kline