To start, there are are three Watchmen continuities to choose from...
The original comics: Watchmen, Before Watchmen, and Doomsday Clock
The film universe: Watchmen: The End Is Nigh, Zack Snyder's Watchmen, Under the Hood, and Tales of the Black Freighter
The HBO continuity: Watchmen, HBO's Watchmen, Peteypedia, and Rorschach
This wiki is kind of a mess, and part of that is because we squish all the info from each continuity onto a single page! If we could have, say, three pages for each continuity (maybe two because the film is very similar to the comics and could easily function as trivia on their pages) it'd be a lot easier to keep track of. We could use tabs to organize them, like the ones on the Witcher wiki. To simplify, I hope someday we can have these three DIFFERENT pages: Hooded Justice, Hooded Justice (Snyder), and Will Reeves. Another example would be Jon Osterman, Jon Osterman (Snyder), and Jon Osterman (HBO). Snyder could be swapped for "film", it doesn't really matter.
That sound like a good idea?